|
Diving is a potentially
hazardous activity. The materials contained within
this magazine are for informational purposes only and are
not intended as a substitute for proper and appropriate training.
|

|
Part of the Team: RAN
Mine Counter Measures Divers
|
|
By David Strike
|

|
An RAN Mine Counter Measures
Diver checks the fuse wiring of a recovered mine.
|
|
Accounting
for more shipping losses during the Second World War
than any other weapon, mines - and the measures developed
to neutralise them - have played a pivotal role
in the evolution of military diving. It's
a relationship symbolised in the crest of the Royal Australian
Navy's Clearance Diving Branch of a diving helmet superimposed
onto a tethered mine.
Unlike the contact mines of WWII, the influence mines of today are technologically sophisticated packages triggered by acoustics, changes in pressure, magnetic influences, or any combination of the three. Rather than detonating against the hull of a ship unlucky enough to run into them, an influence mine is positioned on the seabed in up to 40 or more metres of water. Activated when a target vessel passes overhead the mine detonates, creating a huge gas bubble of vaporised water that, expanding as it ascends, forms a hole in the water beneath the ship. Unable to remain afloat, the ship falls into the hole, breaks its back and sinks. |
|
Combating this threat
is akin to playing a game of three dimensional
chess in turbid waters, tidal flows, currents, silt and
shifting sea beds - an evolving art form rather than a science
and one in which the mine counter measures element attempts to second
guess the minefield planner's intentions and the technology that
he's using.
Despite an impressive array of mine counter measures resources - that includes purpose built vessels like the new 'Huon' Class Mine Hunters armed with sonar and ROV's - the shallow water approaches to ports and harbours, as well as the areas around wharves and buoys, still require the services of divers. |
|
For Lieutenant
Commander Peter Day, overseeing Mine
Counter Measures is an important aspect of
his job as Commanding Officer of Australian Clearance Diving
Team One, one of the world's elite diving forces.
Functioning as self-sufficient units capable of almost indefinite deployment into the field, the R. A. N.'s two Clearance Diving Teams (AUSCDT One, based at HMAS Waterhen in Sydney, and AUSCDT Four at HMAS Sterling in Perth), each consist of about sixty personnel organised around an identical Command structure. With a Commanding Officer, Executive Officer, Warrant Officer and full support personnel, each Team supports three fighting elements - the UBDR (Underwater Battle Damage Repair); the MTO (Maritime Tactical Operations); and MCM (Mine Counter Measures) - two of whom (the MTO and the MCM) have Mine Counter Measures functions. |

|
(The following article first
appeared in, 'Professional Diver Journal', 1999)
|
|
Its a mine
|
|
Structured along identical lines
each element consists of one Officer, responsible for maintaining the
operational readiness of his section and a Chief Petty Officer who,
as well as being a diving specialist, attends to the day to day maintenance
of those specific skills, (like weapons and small arms
training, bush navigation and combat survival training), that
give the teams their operational edge.
Not all mines are targeted against shipping. On occasion they're employed against the mine counter measures assets themselves; the mine sweepers and mine hunters that perform the Deep Water (DW) operations; as well as divers carrying out VSW (Very Shallow Water) and SW (Shallow Water) detection and disposal. Mines are also a potent weapon in halting or slowing down amphibious beach landings. |
|
While those mines
seeded below the high water mark are targeted
against amphibious landing vessels, those placed
above it are usually of the anti-
personnel variety. Rendering these mines safe is a function of the amphibious reconnaissance divers of MTO. As a clandestine force going in under cover of darkness, the MTO operate in Very Shallow Water, placing charges on all of those mines that they discover in a field before retreating and firing them remotely. The overt mine counter measures responsibility, (that of disposing of mines discovered in Shallow Water), belongs to the MCM element themselves. (Although capable of operating effectively to much deeper depths, the operational training focuses on the shallower ranges, roughly between 9 and 45-metres, where reduced decompression obligations apply.) |
|
"Although a diver
is unlikely to be the target of a minefield
planner, there's always a
degree of uncertainty when dealing with a live piece
of ordnance." Says Lt Cdr Peter
Day. "Our tactics
are developed to determine how far off we can
reasonably approach a known mine
type to place a charge.
But that's a known mine. It's possible to
have a completely different set of
algorithms and instrumentation within a mine of the same
shape. You can never be certain exactly
what's inside it!
"To keep our divers as safe as possible our tactics for dealing with mines are developed around the worst case scenario. For that reason we conduct a stringent series of checks on the diver and his equipment before he enters the water to ensure that they both have as low a magnetic and acoustic signature as possible," |
|
Training
The RAN conducts three levels of training for Clearance Diving Mine Counter Measures operations. Basic training for a Navy Clearance Diver is in the order of six months. Approximately one quarter of that time is spent in MCM training, with a similar period devoted to ordnance disposal functions for mines. During that time the diver learns to use the specialised diving equipment employed by the MCM element; the search techniques used to find and safely identify underwater ordnance; and how to prepare charges. Once a diver attains a certain rank and seniority they become eligible for advanced training. This teaches them to supervise both the diving and the MCM operation; the best type of search to employ in the prevailing environmental conditions; the proced- ures for rendering the mine safe, (a manoeuvre that usually takes place underwater), recovery of the mine to the surface and the extraction of its instrumentation package. The route for Clearance Diving Officers is even more demanding. Having first gained their Bridge Watch Keeping ticket, completed the full Clearance Diving course and carried out the same advanced MCM level training as the senior sailors, the officers also receive further schooling in Mine Warfare. Dealing with mine sweeping, mine hunting, command and control of Mine Counter Measures and Mine Warfare operations, mine laying , and the use and purpose of specific equipment carried on board the various ships, the Mine Warfare course trains the officer to recognise mine shapes, their characteristics (whether, for example, they're 'woken up' by an acoustic signature and fired on a magnetic impulse), and - with a reasonable degree of certainty - what threat that particular piece of ordnance poses for the operator who must deal with it. Armed with this comprehensive view of Mine Warfare and Mine Counter Measures, the Mine Warfare and Clearance Diving Officer is able to pit known mine types against particular Mine Counter Measures platforms (a diver or a ship) and - because it's impossible to be certain about what is inside a mine - in developing tactics for dealing with them. |
|
Because Mine
Counter Measures diving requires
relatively long duration underwater, coupled with
a need for both acoustic and mag-
netic hygiene, the MCM divers use the A5800 semi-closed heliox rebreather (a derivative of the USN Mk 16), with a depth capability of 90+ metres. Even the diving knives are made of beryllium, a metal so toxic that it will poison anyone unfortunate enough cut themselves on the blade! "It's an evolving field and as a new mine type comes into the picture we develop tactics to dive against it." Peter Day continues. "We carry out considerable research to determine what a piece of ordnance is and what the procedure is to render it safe. |
|
"To maintain the skills
to do that requires continuous training. If
the publications we use
on mine identification or
Render Safe Procedures are not complete, or
if the information just isn't available, we still
have to deal with the job. In those instances we
rely on the judgement of the person
tasked with rendering the mine safe. He
doesn't rely on guesswork! They're all carefully
considered actions based on knowledge and experience of
dealing with a particular mine type
and which
are then incorporated into the data base on dealing
with that specific threat.
|
|
"We also work
closely with the DSTO ( Defence Science
and Technology Organisation) in developing procedures
against certain types of mines. They provide a lot
of the intellectual input that help us develop appropriate
tactics."
|
|
While mine technology has taken
a quantum leap, searching for
them remains a painstaking and
patient process. Parallel jack-stays are
laid along the sea floor allowing progressive
scrutiny of the area to be searched. Working in pairs
divers can employ a snag-line strung between
them or, because it's possible to initiate the firing train in
a sensitive mine, they may use hand held
sonar units to seek out a target.
Containing sophisticated electronic pack- ages a direct approach on to a mine is fraught with risk. (The mine may, for example, have an acoustic trigger to 'wake' it up and a magnetic trigger to initiate the firing mechanism. A whale swimming past won't cause it to explode but a targeted ship, with metal in it, will!). For this reason the searching diver, having detected a mine, places a marker in the vicinity to help guide the supervisor to its position. |

|
Unless the mine is the
first find of its type, and therefore one that needs to be brought to
the surface for 'exploitation', then the preferred
method of disposal is to detonate it in situ by placing
a charge right beside it. More often
than not, however, the mine's close
proximity to sensitive areas makes it necessary
to render it safe before bringing it to the surface
for examination and disposal.
|
|
The Render Mines Safe
(RMS) procedure is
carried out by the Supervisor who places and remotely detonates an explosive charge in the vicinity of the mine (rather than on the mine itself, a process which may trigger a sympathetic detonation!). The aim is to collapse the instrumentation and disrupt the firing mechanism through over pressurisation. |
|
The supervisor will then
carry out a verification dive to look for cracks
in the mine's casing, air bubbles, or other signs that the charge
has rendered the mine safe for handling. Ideally the RMS
procedure cracks the casing and floods the electronic componentry.
The person supervising each job is the person who determines when the mine is safe to move. (On one mine tackled by AUSCDT Three during the Gulf War - an Italian, 'Manta' with a fibre glass body making crack detection difficult to see - the procedure had to be carried out three times before the supervisor felt confident enough to continue with the surface lift.) Once the supervisor is satisfied that the RS procedures have been effective a lifting bag, made of non-magnetic material, is attached and - when the team has withdrawn to a safe distance - remotely activated. Once on the surface a towline attached to the lifting bag is used to move the mine to a pre- determined beach where, in about 2-metres of water, a transition buoy and tow rope have previously been positioned. |
|
After connecting the tow line
and tow rope together with karabiners the rest of the team
retreats, leaving the supervisor - who is positioned
outside of the mine's blast and fragmentation
range - to remotely pull the mine up onto the beach and
into position under a tripod where he can
work on removing the mine's fuses.
"Ideally we like to have the tripod pre-set so that the supervisor spends as little time as is necessary working over the mine." Explains Chief Petty Officer Steve Woodman, one of four Clearance Divers to be awarded the Conspicuous Service Medal for EOD work in Kuwait during and after the Gulf War. There is always the risk that the render safe charge has only made the mine's sensors temporarily 'dizzy' rather than disabling them. A situation in which the mine, alerted by movement will wake up, 'look' at what is approaching and, if it perceives a threat, initiate detonation. |

|
Both above
and below the water, the diving
Supervisor usually adopts a 'one-in-three' approach to a mine,
taking one step then stopping
and counting to three. Activated by the
movement the mine will 'wake' up, 'look' and, failing to
detect further activity, turn itself off and
go back to sleep. This procedure is repeated until the supervisor
is close enough to visually examine the mine
and determine the appropriate course of action
"You have to remember", says Steve Woodman, "that its been on the bottom of the sea; it's had a big explosive charge initiated close to it; it's been lifted from the seabed to the surface; it's been towed - bobbing around, through the |
|
water - and it's been dragged
up onto the beach. If it hasn't initiated in all that time then
there's probably a good chance that it's not going
to. However!!!!
|
|
"The operator may drop
the 'One-in-Three' approach", he continues, "and walk straight
in without taking that precaution. He may, for
example, say, 'This is definitely not a magnetic mine', and he'll
dispense with magnetic hygiene, wear his watch and use
a normal screwdriver as opposed to using
one made of beryllium, or other non-ferrous material.
It's his call.
"Usually, however, there's nothing metallic on the operator and even the nuts, screws or bolts removed in order to extract the fuse are left on the casing so that there is no change or disruption to the magnetic field." Having removed all of the retaining devices, a bridle is attached to the fuse and hooked on to the towline. Again retreating to an area outside the blast and fragmentation range, the supervisor will remotely lift out the fuse to a position where, on his return, he is able to look into the well and check the wiring. Once he's convinced that the mine has the wires, cables and sensors that it's supposed to have then he can be fairly confident that it hasn't been tampered with. |
|
Research will tell him what
procedures to follow. "There might, for example, be
eight wires", says Steve Woodman, "and the operator has
to first cut the blue wire followed by the white wire. The
decision on what to do is his alone. He may cut it,
or he may decide to try and do it remotely by using one
or other of the tools in our render safe arsenal.
We can fire bolts to sever fuses or use water
jets to disrupt a package or thin-skinned munition."
While locating mines and placing charges, particularly in murky waters or strong currents, is dangerous work, mine counter measures forms only part of the Clearance Diver's role in EOD (Explosive Ordnance Disposal). He's also called upon to deal with surface threats, from bombs, Improvised Explosive Devices (IED) and booby traps through to ordnance from WWII. |
|
Because there will always
be, in the foreseeable future, a role for a guy to go down
and dive on a mine, AUSCDT One (and AUSCDT
Four) are constantly honing all of their many
skill levels. Working closely with the Americans
(the Teams have two exchange positions with
their American counterparts) and other countries
around the region, the Team divers maintain
their readiness through continuous operational training with other
Forces.
"It's a situation that benefits all parties", says Lt. Cdr. Peter Day, "and one that ensures an equal transfer of information. It's certainly not one-way traffic! Our Clearance Divers' are very capable people with exceptional abilities who provide the RAN with a range of skills not found in other Navies." And with just two operational Teams, the Clearance Divers of AUSCDT One and AUSCDT Four are among Australia's scarcest assets. |
AUSCDT Three in the Gulf In January, 1991, AUSCDT Three was reformed with personnel from across the force and was despatched to Bahrain to help the U.S. Marines prepare for the proposed amphibious invasion of Iraqi occupied Kuwait. As Operation Desert Storm progressed the requirement for an amphibious assault lessened, the Team's primary mission became the Explosive Ordnance Disposal [EOD] clearance of the ports of Kuwait. The twenty-three man team entered Kuwait by land on the 5th March. Joining almost fifty other divers from the US and Royal Navies they began the dangerous task of clearing wharves and warehouses of unexploded ordnance and booby traps before entering the oil blackened waters of the harbour to search for, and dispose, of sea mines. During the next seven days AUSCDT Three cleared over 450,000 square meters of seabed, searching for both buoyant contact and influence ground mines. An effort that represented seventy per cent of the harbour area cleared by coalition forces by the time the port re-opened to shipping. Their efforts weren't restricted to below the surface operations. During this time the Team also rendered safe three Iraqi seamines, carried out booby trap clearance on a nearby oil refinery and assisted US personnel to recover six anti-ship missiles from the Kuwaiti Girls Science High School. Moving south, AUSCDT Three were next tasked with clearing the Kuwaiti Naval Base of Ras Al Qualai Ah. The ten day operation involved removing booby traps and rendering safe thirty-one sea mines. Back in Kuwait City the Team continued work on clearing the harbours and beaches that were Kuwait's lifeline with the world. On the 11th May, after three and a half months deployed, AUSCDT Three returned to Australia to be disbanded and members returned to their parent Teams. During their time in the field they had cleared four ports, dealt with 60 seamines, cleared 234,986 pieces of ordnance and searched an astonishing 2,157,200 square metres of sea bed! They lost count of the number of booby traps that they had to contend with! AUSCDT Three had distinguished itself well in Kuwait and earned for the RAN Clearance Diving Branch an international reputation for skill and professionalism. Recognition of their achievements included the award of two Conspicuous Service Cross's, 1 Order Of Australia Medal, 4 Conspicuous Service Medals, an Australian Meritorious Unit Citation and an Admiral's Commendation. |